The Canadian stock market was down sharply Friday as a stronger than expected U.S. jobs report failed to provide investors with sufficient comfort to offset worries about a slowing American economy and a lack of leadership in coming to grips with the U.S or the European debt crisis.
It was another “yo-yo” day, with the S&P/TSX composite index dropping 217.96 points or 1.76% to 12,162.17, after having dropped almost 450 points earlier in the day. Investors took some comfort that it wasn’t worse.
Friday’s drop, which came a day after the index had its biggest single-day drop in more than 2 years, were led by sliding resource stocks amid investor sentiment that slowing economic conditions will heavily impact demand for commodities.
On the week the index dropped 6.3% or 783 points, leaving the S&P/TSX down almost 10% year to date.
Late Friday, Standard & Poors said it had downgraded the United States’ credit rating for the 1st time in history. It slashed the country’s top AAA rating by one notch to AA+. It said it made the move because the deficit reduction plan passed by Congress did not go far enough to stabilize the country’s debt situation.
Earlier Friday, markets moved off the worst levels of the day as Italy pledged to work for a constitutional amendment requiring the government to balance its budget in 2013, a year before previously scheduled.
Italian and Spanish bonds have traded at levels that threaten the ability of those countries to raise money in the bond markets to pay off debt. In short, the European debt crisis is no longer limited to just Greece.
Canadian job numbers did not exceed expectations but at 7,100 it was still not bad, especially if you looked into the details.
Stock markets were no better in the United States this past week. Stocks closed out their worst week in more than 2 years in a volatile week.

On Friday more than 15.9 billion shares traded (more than twice the daily average). The market moved, initially jumping up on the employment news, and then down and then up again. The Dow Jones industrial average covered 416.41 points from its day high to its intraday low.
The intense selling last week reflects frustration with sluggish economic growth and politicians’ inability to address pressing concerns over high public debt in Europe and the United States.
The Chicago Board of Options Exchange (CBOE) Volatility Index or VIX, Wall Street’s so-called “fear” gauge, rose as high as 39.25 within the day, its highest level since May 2010. The volatility index is up almost 90% during the past 2 weeks, as fears about the European debt crisis, the global economy and earnings have taken a heavy toll on investor sentiment. The S&P 500 is now down 12% from its April 29th closing high for the year (14% if you count the intra-day low on Friday).
Markets have been looking to European officials for guidance as to how the region’s debt crisis will be managed. The loss of confidence is coming from the inadequate response to the growing threat to large euro-zone economies Spain and Italy and banks’ exposure to their troubled debt.
In the United States, non-farm payrolls data showed a gain of 117,000 jobs in July compared with a forecast for an increase of 85,000, while the country’s unemployment rate dipped to 9.1% last month from 9.2% in June.
The Dow Jones industrial average rose 60.93 points, or 0.54%, to end at 11,444.61. However, the Standard & Poor’s 500 Index edged down 0.06%, to finish at 1,199.38. The Nasdaq Composite Index slipped 23.98 points, or 0.94%, to close at 2,532.41.
For the week, the Dow fell 5.8%, the S&P 500 was down 7.2% and the Nasdaq was off 8.1%.
Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi said his country will introduce a constitutional principle of a balanced budget in an effort to reduce debt levels. Helping the market erase big losses in afternoon trade, sources said the European Central Bank was ready to buy Italian and Spanish bonds if Berlusconi commits to bringing forward specific reforms.
The impact of a downgrade of U.S. government debt by Standard & Poor’s isn’t higher interest rates. It’s the hit to the nation’s fragile economic spirit and rattled capital markets. This action will deal a blow to the confidence of consumers and businesses at a dangerous time, economists say.
The timing could hardly be worse for the U.S. The economy added 117,000 jobs in July, more than expected. But other economic indicators, including manufacturing, consumer spending and overall growth, are getting weaker.
And the markets just came through their most harrowing two weeks since the financial crisis of 2008. The Dow lost about 10% of its value on fears of a new recession and Europe’s spiraling financial problems.
In normal times, in another country, a downgrade in a country’s sovereign debt rating probably would force its government to pay higher interest rates to convince investors to keep buying its debt. If that happened, it would drive up the rates that consumers pay on mortgages and auto loans, which are often tied to the government’s interest rate. However, the United States is a special case. Treasury debt is considered the safest investment in the world — even after the downgrade. Investors don’t doubt the U.S. government’s ability to repay the trillions it owes.
Anytime there’s a problem anywhere on the world, investors will buy the safety of the U.S., and they don’t go anywhere else.
The Obama administration made its displeasure known quickly after the downgrade was announced. The Treasury Department said S&P had acted on an analysis that had a $2 trillion error. Although, on the weekend President Barack Obama stated that he believes Washington “must do better” tackling the federal budget deficits.
The downgrade itself will become a volatile political issue ahead of next year’s Presidential election in the United States.
The rating agency also said the decision reflected its loss of confidence in the U.S. political system. Republicans and Democrats didn’t reach a deal on debt reduction until hours before the federal government’s borrowing limit was to expire, which would have triggered a U.S. default on its debt or massive, immediate government cuts.
Economists say the downgrade, the 1st since the U.S. received the top rating from S&P in 1941, will rattle consumers and businesses already worried about the weak economy and the U.S. political system’s inability to handle the country’s problems.
America’s reputation has already taken a hit abroad. China, the largest foreign holder of U.S. debt, on Saturday demanded that the United States tighten its belt and overcome its “addiction to debt” in the wake of the S&P downgrade. China’s central bank holds an estimated $1.16 trillion in U.S. debt.
Analysts are quickly starting to “sing a different tune” predicting a volatile stock market with major highs and lows. This will likely be around for months as hints of another possible recession begin to surface amid global economic uncertainty.
We have been there before, 3 years ago, when the Wall Street banking crisis sparked a global recession and trillions of dollars in losses on the world’s stock exchanges. Experts advise investors not to panic, keep focused on quality stocks and try to ride out the storm of volatility, which should be around for months.
Some are concerned the economy could double dip from recession to tepid recovery and then back into recession, once government stimulus programs end. They are also concerned that this could go on for another year of uncertainty. News out of the United States has been grim as the country recorded weak manufacturing numbers, lower consumer spending, and on Friday announced it added just 117,000 jobs in July, bringing the country’s unemployment rate down to 9.1%.
Canada is well positioned to weather the economic troubles because of its resources, including oil, mining, and forestry. As countries like China grow and demand building materials, Canada stands to cash in. But the United States is still the largest buyer of Canadian goods, and some fear that country could be stumbling back into a recession.
Stock markets have fallen before and will likely fall again, but investors get riled up over the chaos each time which further compounds the volatility. Last week’s steep sell-off wiped about $2.5 trillion off global market valuations and more than $4 trillion from the recent peak. The index has retreated 11% in the last 11 days.
This morning analysts said the S&P 500 index could test Friday’s intraday low of 1,168.09 or about a 2.0% drop today. However, some investors are arguing that “The market is grossly oversold”, valuations are attractive and a lot of “re-pricing” of assets have already materialized.
This morning we see Gold hitting another record high of $1,715.01 an ounce and it could post the 2nd largest daily gain this year. Resource-related stocks will be under pressure as crude oil prices fell 3.7% to below $84 a barrel on concerns over the economic outlook.
In a hope to avert panic spreading across financial markets, the finance ministers and central bankers of the Group of 20 industrial and developing nations issued a joint statement saying they were committed to taking all necessary measures to support financial stability and growth. Interesting enough the value of U.S. government bonds has not changed during this rating cut.
Regards,
Wilfred Vos Bcs, FMA, CIM, CFP, FCSI, DMS, CBV, MBA, CFA
SVP & Partner